| Nominating Player | Coach |
| First Name | Last Name | Team | First Name | Last Name | High School | City | State |
| Mark | Simoneau | New Orleans Saints | Roger | Barta | Smith Center Junior/Senior HS | Smith Center | KS |
| Brooks | Bollinger | Minnesota Vikings | Mike | Berg | Central HS | Grand Forks | ND |
| Max | Starks | Pittsburg Steelers | Tim | Borcky | Lake Highland Prep School | Orlando | FL |
| Victor | Hobson | New York Jets | Gil | Brooks | St. Joseph Preparatory School | Philadelphia | PA |
| Nick | Turnbull | *currently free agent, formerly of Atlanta Falcons | Larry | Brown | Charles W. Flanagan HS | Pembroke Pines | FL |
| D'Brickashaw | Ferguson | New York Jets | Russ | Cellan | Freeport HS | Freeport | NY |
| Will | Heller | Seattle Seahawks | Alan | Chadwick | Marist School | Atlanta | GA |
| Marcus | Trufant | Seattle Seahawks | Don | Clegg | Wilson HS | Tacoma | WA |
| Brad | Hoover | Carolina Panthers | Dickie | Cline | Robert B. Glenn HS | Kernersville | NC |
| Charlie | Anderson | Houston Texans | Willie | Collins | Provine HS | Jackson | MS |
| Fred | Smoot | Washington Redskins | Willie | Collins | Provine HS | Jackson | MS |
| Darryl | Tapp | Seattle Seahawks | David | Cox | Deep Creek HS | Chesapeake | VA |
| Tully | Banta-Cain | San Francisco 49ers | Ron | Demonner | Fremont HS | Sunnyvale | CA |
| Michael | Kracalik | Baltimore Ravens | Trace | Deneke | El Camino HS | Oceanside | CA |
| Chris | Pino | *currently free agent, formerly of Baltimore Ravens | Trace | Deneke | El Camino HS | Oceanside | CA |
| Nick | Mangold | New York Jets | Ed | Domsitz | Archbishop Alter HS | Kettering | OH |
| Kevin | Burnett | Dallas Cowboys | Keith | Donerson | Manuel E Dominquez HS | Compton | CA |
| Tony | Wragge | San Francisco 49ers | Jim | Dooley | Bloomfield Community HS | Bloomfield | NE |
| Gerard | Ross | *currently free agent, formerly with Seattle Seahawks | Verlon | Dorminey | Trinity Christian Academy | Jacksonville | FL |
| Will | Smith | New Orleans Saints | Jerry | Fiorini | Thomas R. Proctor HS | Utica | NY |
| Erasmus | James | Minnesota Vikings | Keith | Franklin | McArthur HS | Ft. Lauderdale | FL |
| Santana | Moss | Washington Redskins | Walt | Frazier | Miami Carol City Senior HS | Miami | FL |
| Sinorice | Moss | New York Giants | Walt | Frazier | Miami Carol City Senior HS | Miami | FL |
| Akbar | Gbaja-Biamila | Miami Dolphins | Robert | Garrett | Princeville HS | Los Angeles | CA |
| Jayme | Mitchell | Minnesota Vikings | Bill | Giles | Forest Hill HS | Jackson | MS |
| Charlie | Batch | Pittsburg Steelers | Jack | Giran | Steel Valley HS | Munhall | PA |
| Aaron | Stecker | New Orleans Saints | Ken | Golomski | Ashwaubenon HS | Ashwaubenon | WI |
| Renaldo | Wynn | New Orleans Saints | James | Grannan | DeLaSalle Institute | Chicago | IL |
| Trai | Essex | Pittsburg Steelers | Sherwood | Haydock | Paul Harding HS | Ft. Wayne | IN |
| Mike | Smith | Baltimore Ravens | Butch | Henderson | Coronado HS | Lubbock | TX |
| Keith | Bulluck | Tennessee Titans | Ed | Henry | Clarkstown HS North | New City | NY |
| David | Thornton | Tennessee Titans | Elvin | James | Goldsboro HS | Goldsboro | NC |
| Vernon | Davis | San Francisco 49ers | Craig | Jefferies | Dunbar HS | Washington | DC |
| Brandon | Williams | St. Louis Rams | Corey | Johnson | Hazelwood East HS | St. Louis | MO |
| Brett | Keisel | Pittsburg Steelers | Phil | Juillard | Greybull HS | Greybull | WY |
| Jason | Allen | Miami Dolphins | Charles "Cody" | Keene | Muscle Shoals HS | Muschle Shoals | AL |
| Nate | Burleson | Seattle Seahawks | Monte | Kohler | O'Dea HS | Seattle | WA |
| Jason | Brown | Baltimore Ravens | Randy | Long | Northern Vance HS | Henderson | NC |
| David | Carr | Carolina Panthers | Dave | Lonsinger | Stockdale HS | Bakersfield | CA |
| Oshiomogho | Atogwe | St. Louis Rams | Harry | Lumley | W.F. Herman Secondary School | Windsor | Ontario, Canada |
| Tye | Hill | St. Louis Rams | Brian | Mahan | Woodland HS | Dorchester | SC |
| Laveranues | Coles | New York Jets | Arthur | Mallory | Jean Ribault HS | Jacksonville | FL |
| Thomas | Davis | Carolina Panthers | Jim | McFather | Randolph Clay HS | Cuthbert | GA |
| Ryan | Nece | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | Jim | McGary | Golden Valley Middle School | San Bernadino | CA |
| Geoffrey | Pope | New York Giants | Scott | Merchant | Detroit Jesuit HS | Detroit | MI |
| Drew | Mormino | Miami Dolphins | Bill | Mitz | Adlai E. Stephenson HS | Lincolnshire | IL |
| Adewale | Ogunleye | Chicago Bears | Jim | Munson | Tottenville HS | Staten Island | NY |
| Omar | Stoutmire | *currently free agent, formerly of Washington Redskins | Don | Norford | Long Beach Poly HS | Long Beach | CA |
| Sean | Ryan | New York Jets | Robert | O'Connor, Jr. | St. Joseph's Collegiate Institute | Buffalo | NY |
| Willie | Colon | Pittsburg Steelers | C.J. | O'Neil | Cardinal Hayes HS | Bronx | NY |
| Travis | Kirschke | Pittsburg Steelers | Bill | Pendleton | Esperanza HS | Anaheim | CA |
| Christopher | Vedder | *currently free agent, formerly of Miami Dolphins | John | Petty | Sierra HS | Manteca | CA |
| Mike | Karney | New Orleans Saints | Kurt | Phelps | Kentwood HS | Kent | WA |
| David | Lofton | *currently free agent, formerly of Miami Dolphins | Mark | Reeve | Plano West HS | Plano | TX |
| Matt | Roth | Miami Dolphins | Jeff | Reher | Willowbrook HS | Villa Park | IL |
| EJ | Henderson | Minnesota Vikings | Kevin | Reilly | Aberdeen HS | Aberdeen | MD |
| Anthony | Adams | Chicago Bears | James | Reynolds | Martin Luther King HS | Detroit | MI |
| Kyle | Vanden Bosch | Tennessee Titans | Jay | Rozeboom | West Lyon Community HS | Inwood | IA |
| Jordan | Gross | Carolina Panthers | Bruce | Schlaich | Fruitland HS | Fruitland | ID |
| Stephen | Parker | *currently free agent, formerly of Miami Dolphins | Ken | Sears | St. Paul's School | Covington | LA |
| DJ | Shockley | Atlanta Falcons | Don | Shockley | North Clayton HS | College Park | GA |
| Bradie | James | Dallas Cowboys | Don | Shows | West Monroe HS | West Monroe | LA |
| Kwame | Harris | San Francisco 49ers | Butch | Simpson | Newark HS | Newark | DE |
| Tim | Hasselbeck | Arizona Cardinals | Charlie | Stevenson | Xaverian Brothers HS | Westwood | MA |
| Ryan | Boschetti | Washington Redskins | Terry | Stogner | Carlmont HS | Belmont | CA |
| Chris | Hoke | Pittsburgh Steelers | Dan | Stroup | Foothill HS | Santa Ana | CA |
| Leon | Washington | New York Jets | Kevin | Sullivan | Andrew Jackson Senior HS | Jacksonville | FL |
| Joey | Harrington | Atlanta Falcons | Terry | Summerfield | Sam Barlow HS | Gresham | OR |
| William | Whitticker | *currently free agent, formerly of Washington Redskins | Mark | Surface | Marion HS | Marion | IN |
| Scott | Young | Philadelphia Eagles | Bruce | Takeno | Hillcrest HS | Midvale | UT |
| Cedrick | Wilson | Pittsburgh Steelers | Tim | Thompson | Fayette - Ware HS | Somerville | TN |
| Ryan | Clark | Pittsburgh Steelers | Hank | Tierney | West Jefferson HS | Harvey | LA |
| Jamaal | Jackson | Philadelphia Eagles | Earl | Tillman | Booker T. Washington Senior HS | Miami | FL |
| Mkristo | Bruce | Oakland Raiders | Steve | Valach | Liberty Senior HS | Renton | WA |
| Greg | Warren | Pittsburg Steelers | Bob | Warren | Southern Wayne HS | Dudley | NC |
| Spencer | Johnson | Minnesota Vikings | Stacy | Watters | Sumter County HS | York | AL |
| Donnie | Jones | St. Louis Rams | Dale | Weiner | Catholic HS | Baton Rouge | LA |
| Babatunde | Oshinowo | Chicago Bears | Bryan | Wells | Neuqua Valley HS | Naperville | IL |
| Brian | Simmons | New Orleans Saints | Chip | Williams | New Bern HS | New Bern | NC |
| Ross | Tucker | Washington Redskins | Bob | Wolfrum | Wyomissing Area Junior/Senior HS | Wyomissing | PA |
| DeMeco | Ryans | Houston Texans | William | Woodham | Jess Lanier HS | Bessemer | AL |
| Brad | Maynard | Chicago Bears | Larry "Bud" | Wright | Sheridan HS | Sheridan | IN |
| Deshea | Townsend | Pittsburgh Steelers | Willis | Wright | South Panola HS | Batesveille | MS |